Does the mode of instruction influence the effectiveness of computer-related pain relief exercises?

In an era dominated by computer use, musculoskeletal pain among office workers has become a prevalent concern. Long hours spent at computer workstations often lead to discomfort and distress. In 2010, a study conducted by Allen H. Marangoni, et. al., aimed to investigate the efficacy of regular stretching exercises in alleviating musculoskeletal pain associated with prolonged computer use. Furthermore, the study delved into whether the mode of instruction delivery had any bearing on the outcomes.

The research enlisted sixty-eight volunteers, all of whom were grappling with computer-related pain for at least three weeks prior to the study. These participants were subjected to a meticulous examination of the impact of stretching exercises on their discomfort.

The study employed a robust pretest-posttest-control group design with cluster randomization. Over a span of 15-17 workdays, participants performed a comprehensive regimen of thirty-six distinct stretches. Two intervention groups were instructed to engage in stretching exercises at six-minute intervals. The first group, consisting of 22 individuals, received reminders through a computer program, while the second group, comprising 23 individuals, relied on a hard copy version containing illustrated instructions. Meanwhile, a control group underwent no intervention.

The results were striking. Analysis of variance (ANOVA) unveiled a noteworthy reduction in pain for both intervention groups. Remarkably, the computer-generated stretching program led to an astonishing 72% decrease in pain (p < 0.001), while the hard copy version achieved a significant 64% reduction (p < 0.001). In contrast, the control group experienced a slight 1% increase in pain.

The implications of these findings are profound. They underscore the effectiveness of stretching exercises in mitigating musculoskeletal pain arising from computer use. Equally important is the revelation that the mode of instruction delivery, whether through computer software or hard copy materials, did not substantially alter the outcomes. This is particularly noteworthy as it suggests that individuals can choose the instructional medium that best suits their preferences and access.

It is noteworthy that these reductions in pain were achieved without the need for any adjustments to workstation ergonomics, which further enhances the practicality of this approach. Furthermore, the study employed subjective assessments, including visual analog scales and a novel “pain spot” evaluation technique, both of which reinforced the consistency and reliability of the results.

In conclusion, Marangoni’s study sheds light on a simple yet effective solution to the pervasive issue of musculoskeletal pain associated with computer use. By incorporating regular stretching exercises into one’s routine, individuals can significantly reduce discomfort without the need for complex ergonomic changes. Moreover, the flexibility in instructional media empowers users to select the format that suits them best, making this approach accessible to a wide range of individuals in today’s computer-centric workplaces.

Reference: Marangoni, A. H. (2010). Effects of intermittent stretching exercises at work on musculoskeletal pain associated with the use of a personal computer and the influence of media on outcomes. Work36(1), 27-37.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *